Aug. 11, 2021
Pentagon Press Secretary John F. Kirby
PRESS SECRETARY JOHN F. KIRBY: Good afternoon,
everybody. A couple of things at the top, as soon as I get this thing to
load. Think you saw our readout, the Secretary did speak by phone
earlier today with the Russian Minister of Defense, Sergey Shoygu. The
purpose of the call was to support transparency and risk-reduction
efforts following the July 28th resumption of the U.S.-Russia Strategic
Stability Dialogue in Geneva, Switzerland.
Onto other personnel issues, last night the Senate confirmed Gil
Cisneros as Undersecretary for Personnel and Readiness, and we look
forward to welcoming Gil here to the Pentagon, glad to have him on
board. And we now have 21 nominees to be confirmed by the Senate.
Additionally, the Senate confirmed Army Lieutenant General Laura
Richardson to command U.S. Southern Command, and receive her fourth
star. And so, again, we're looking forward to seeing her transition into
that new role and to assume command at the appropriate time.
Lastly, I -- just to level set, I have seen lots of press reporting
this morning about assessments coming out of Afghanistan. Just before I
-- I know you're all interested in that, let me tell you, I am not going
to talk specifically about intelligence assessments one way or the
other. We continue to monitor the situation in Afghanistan closely. We
are mindful of the deteriorating security situation. And our focus right
now remains on supporting the Afghan forces in the field where and when
feasible we can from the air, as well as completing our drawdown in a
safe and orderly way. We are on track to do that by the end of the
month.
Lastly, we are also remaining focused on the future bilateral
relationship with Afghan forces that will be largely in a financial way
and over-the-horizon support. As well as making sure that we maintain
the capabilities we need to protect the homeland from any terrorist
threats that might be emanating from Afghanistan in an over-the-horizon
fashion.
So again, seeing the press reporting I'm not going to confirm or deny
the figures that some of you have been reporting. We don't talk about
intelligence assessments. Our focus is on getting this drawdown done in a
safe and orderly way.
With that we'll go to Lita.
Q: Thanks John. All right, I've got to take a stab at this, OK? Has
the United States accelerated it's planning for a withdrawal or
evacuation of any Americans from Afghanistan, specifically Kabul,
considering this deteriorating situation that everyone can see? And, or
has the Pentagon moved any additional either forces or assets into the
region to help do some type of evacuation or is that expected in the
coming days?
MR. KIRBY: I have no planning to speak to today, Lita. And I have no
force movement or operational transitions to speak to as well today.
Q: And just as a follow-up has the situation deteriorated faster than
the U.S. was planning such that is there a belief that the U.S. may
have to get out or get at least some people out before the end of
August?
MR. KIRBY: Again, I'm not going to speculate about contingencies in,
you know, and speculate about the future and the future security
situation. We're focused on the security situation that we face now,
which again we've acknowledged is deteriorating. We are certainly
mindful of the advances that the Taliban have made in terms of taking
over yet an increased number of provincial capitals.
And our focus is on supporting the Afghans in the field where and
when we can and completing this drawdown. And I'm not going to speak
about planning contingencies or potential outcomes.
And the other thing I'd say is that no potential outcome has to be
inevitable, including the fall of Kabul, which everybody seems to be
reporting about. It doesn't have to be that way.
And I think it's going to be -- it really depends on the kind of
political and military leadership that the Afghans can muster to turn
this around. They have the capability, they have the capacity and now
it's really time to use those things.
Yes, Nazira?
Q: Thank you, John. I don't know how should I ask my question. I
cannot express my people's situation. We have 300,000 Army. As President
Biden said the Taliban is 73,000 people.
How can the Afghan Army and Afghan police not be able to defeat
Taliban? It's a high number, 300,000 -- we have our -- what is the main
reason that they are not able to fight against the Taliban. Taliban is
very close to Kabul.
MR. KIRBY: We have seen -- we have seen them fight and contest areas.
As for why in any given place the Taliban continue to make advances,
that's really not a question that we're prepared to answer here at the
Pentagon. This is an Afghan military strategy that we are trying to
support as best we can and it really is going to come down to their
leadership.
They have, as you rightly said, they have the advantage in numbers,
in operational structure, in air forces and in modern weaponry and it's
really about having the will and the leadership to use those advantages
to their own benefit.
And I just can't and I won't, as I've been very scrupulous about not
doing from the podium, speak into a daily battlefield assessment when
it's -- these aren't battles that we are involved in on the ground. And
we are -- yes, we are providing some support from the air, but this is
really an Afghan strategy and they should speak to that.
Q: Where did Taliban get their supported, which countries supported them financially and other stuff?
MR. KIRBY: I don't have an assessment of Taliban resources. And so I
wouldn't speculate that there are a nation state or nation states that
are necessarily backing them up. We have definitely seen in some of the
things they've done on the ground have been clearly designed to help
them gain revenue, border crossings, trying to take control over certain
highways and avenues of transportation and communication, ways that
will allow them to support themselves and to gain some revenue. But
beyond that I'm really not at liberty to speculate.
Yes, Megan, did you have a question?
Q: Yes. So you're repeatedly getting these questions about how -- why
the Afghan Army isn't apparently up to snuff and how America could just
walk out on Afghanistan under these conditions.
Do you think the Defense Department could have better -- done a
better job in recent months or in recent years in articulating what the
goals were in Afghanistan and what the -- what things were supposed to
look like or what they're not expected to look like when we leave?
MR. KIRBY: Well, I mean I can't speak for the entire 20 year history
of the war, Megan, but I mean that the war has -- as the President has
said, I mean, the goals did migrate over time.
And it would be -- it would be wrong for us not to acknowledge that
we did help enable some progress in Afghanistan. More children in
schools, including girls, economic and political and social
opportunities for women. A democratically elected government, it's not
saying it's not flawless, but a government. And conditions -- living
conditions that are much better, including life expectancy.
So there has been a lot of progress made over the last 20 years, but
the President made this decision based on his calculus that we have
greater counterterrorism threats that -- against this -- our homeland
and our people and our interests than those that are emanating out of
Afghanistan. That the main purpose for going into Afghanistan in 2001
has been achieved in terms of the significant degradation of the threat
by Al-Qaeda and, of course, the death of Osama Bin Laden.
And that the recipe can't be just a constant U.S. presence in
Afghanistan that never ends. So he's been clear in his direction of what
he expected this Department to do since he became Commander-in-Chief
and that's what we're executing to.
The direction that we've be given to do a couple of things. To draw
down our forces to a level that is only commensurate with helping us
maintain a diplomatic presence. To being able to support and protect
that presence and enable diplomats to continue to do their jobs in
Afghanistan. And then to continue to support the Afghan forces through
financial means and through some contract support and over-the-horizon
logistical support.
And then number four, to make sure that the greatly reduced threat of
terrorism from Afghanistan stays greatly reduced and that the homeland
doesn't become victim to an attack like we did 9/11 20 years ago, from
terrorist networks that are operating out of Afghanistan.
Let me go to the phones here. Jeff Schogol, we'll go to you.
Q: Thank you. Does the U.S. military have any plans to destroy
sensitive Afghan equipment such as their A-29s before the Taliban
achieves its total victory?
MR. KIRBY: Jeff, you're speculating about again an outcome that
doesn't have to be inevitable. So, the short answer to your question is
no. We are focused on supporting the Afghan Forces where and when we
can. And what we, you know, what I think we're all mindful of is that
they have advantages and now is an opportunity for them to use those
advantages, to include political and military leadership.
Ah, Dan Sagalyn.
Q: What is U.S. military’s thinking about what is the Taliban
strategy? What does the U.S. military’s think about why the Taliban are
concentrating in the north?
MR. KIRBY: Dan, I'm not going to speak for Taliban strategy. I think
you can understand why we wouldn't do that. All I can do is tell you
what we're seeing on the ground. And what we're seeing on the ground is
that the Taliban continues to advance and to assume control of district
and provincial centers that clearly indicate that they believe it is
possible to gain governance through force, through brutality, through
violence, through oppression, which is at great odds with their
previously-stated goal of actually wanting to participate in a
negotiated political solution.
Clearly their actions are not in resonance with what they have said
they want to do at the negotiating table. Now what their military
strategy is I think you know they should speak to that. We don't believe
that there is an effective military solution to be had to this
conflict, that the only way through is a political negotiated settlement
that includes all Afghans, that is Afghan-led and that the Afghan
people have a voice and a say in.
Jim.
Q: John is it too late for peace at this point though?
MR. KIRBY: I don't believe anybody thinks it's took late for peace. I
mean we wouldn't be talking about a political settlement and a need to
have a negotiated settlement if we believe that peace wasn't possible.
Yeah, Mike.
Q: Yeah, John, the statement you made, that the recipe can't be a
constant U.S. presence in Afghanistan, it never ends. We've had U.S.
troops in Europe for 70 years, including 20 years after the fall of the
Soviet Union. What's the difference between that situation and
Afghanistan?
MR. KIRBY: We're not in a combat role. We're not in a combat role,
Mike. And that's what the President's talking about. I mean we're still
going to have U.S. Forces in Afghanistan to help protect our diplomatic
presence. What he's talking about is having U.S. Forces in Afghanistan
in a combat role and having this war just never end.
Jeff Selden.
Q: John, thanks very much for doing this. At the White House earlier
this afternoon, Jen Psaki was asked about U.S. air strikes in support
for the Afghan Forces beyond the August 31st deadline. She said it was a
good question. So, is the Defense Department rethinking the kinds of
support it's going to offer Afghan Security Forces beyond that deadline?
And also we keep hearing from you and from others that the Afghan
Security Forces have the capacity, they have the capability to push back
against the Taliban but they need the will.
At what point does that lack of political will to stand up to the
Taliban begin to endanger the embassy in Kabul and other U.S. personnel
and assets that are still in Afghanistan?
MR. KIRBY: Well I mean on your second question, I think that remains
to be seen, Jeff. We do not believe that any of the potential negative
outcomes that we've seen reported have to be inevitable, they have to
happen. And I'm not prepared to go through a series of you know what, at
what factors, what conditions would lead us to believe that no amount
of political military leadership is going to turn the tide. We still
think that that can happen. That through solid political military
leadership, given the advantages that they have, that they can use that.
And I'm sorry you had another, your first question which I completely
blanked on.
Q: The idea of rethinking or giving the Afghan Security Forces more help beyond the August 31st deadline.
MR. KIRBY: Yeah, thank you. Right now the authorities that we have to
support the Afghans from the air expire at the end of this month with
the drawdown. And so we are focused on using the authorities that we
have, the capabilities that we have during the rest of the drawdown to
support Afghan Forces from the air. There has been no policy decision
about what it looks like beyond that and I'm simply not going to
speculate.
Oren.
Q: To what extent did the U.S. underestimate the ability or
capabilities of the Taliban to make these sorts of gains this quickly?
MR. KIRBY: It's not about whether we underestimated or estimated
appropriately. We had seen even before the President's announcement that
the Taliban had been making advances, largely at the district level.
But they're moving in started well before the Biden Administration and
certainly well before the President decided that we were going to
withdraw.
Now, we have certainly seen in recent weeks that progress advance at a
clip, no question about that. It's not about surprise, Oren, it's not
like we weren't watching this. It is obviously we're watching it with
great concern. But I wouldn't say that there was an underestimation
here. What still, I mean, you know we can revisit the past all you want
but what matters really is today and where we are now and again we
believe Afghan Forces have what they need to make a significant
difference and it really is going to come down to leadership.
Q: John, if the Afghan Forces have what they need, why are they losing?
MR. KIRBY: Lucas, I'll try this again. We had this discussion
yesterday. I can't speak for Afghan strategy or Afghan tactics in the
field. What I can tell you is that they do have those advantages,
including, including Lucas, the advantage of additional air support by
the United States, which we continue to provide. We flew strikes,
several strikes there over just the last 24 to 48 hours. So, we're still
supporting them as well and they have advantages that the Taliban
doesn't. And, again, I really think as I said before, when we look back
on this we'll see that it really did come down to leadership, both
political and military.
Q: But John, where's the proof? When you say that Afghan Forces have
advantages over the Taliban, we're just not seeing it on the battlefield
right now.
MR. KIRBY: What I mean is they've got greater numbers, they've got an
air force, and, oh by the way, their air force is also flying. In fact
they're flying more strikes, conducting more strikes than the United
States is. And it's an air force that we continue to contribute to. We
just gave them another three new Black Hawks. Over the course of 20
years, we've 130 some odd air craft to their inventory.
We're still providing contract maintenance support for -- to keep
them flying. This is not an incapable or incompetent Air Force. They --
they know how to fight from the air and they are. They have modern
weaponry. They have military organizational ability as well as 20 years
of training in the field by -- by not just the United States but our
NATO and Allied partners. So they have a lot of advantages. It's really
just now about using those advantages.
Q: Last year the Afghan government let 5,000 Taliban prisoners go free. Has that been helpful?
MR. KIRBY: I can't speak to what each one of those prisoners did,
Lucas. But obviously we don't want to see people rejoin the fight on --
on behalf of the Taliban.
Q: Are you seeing some of those prisoners rejoin --
MR. KIRBY: I don't have any intelligence assessments on that. I don't -- I don't know.
Q: Just overall, do you think the previous Administration’s pressure
to free those prisoners, has that been helpful in the fight against the
Taliban?
MR. KIRBY: What's -- what's been -- what's been helpful against
fighting the Taliban is, again, the kinds of support that the Afghan
forces have received from the United States and from our NATO partners
and that support will continue.
Q: Since they want to release some of the prisoners from the jails,
Taliban says we go to Qatar and make peace but they have a condition. To
release 5,000 more. I don't know if the Afghan government are ready to
--
MR. KIRBY: I can't speak to what's going on in negotiations, Nazira. I
mean obviously we don't want to see anybody who has -- we don't want to
see anybody rejoin the fight on the side of the Taliban. Obviously that
would not be a good outcome.
Q: Is this not the part of the agreement that U.S. sign with them in Doha, Qatar?
MR. KIRBY: I'll let my State Department's -- my State Department
colleagues speak to the agreement in Doha. Our focus, as I said, is on
completing the drawdown, supporting the Afghans when and where we can
and making sure we can protect our diplomatic presence.
Q: Also, Taliban today warning to Turkey and they say you're not
allowed to come and take security for Kabul Airport -- President Karzai
Airport in Afghanistan. I think Afghan government wanted to -- Turkey to
take care of the security of Kabul Airport.
MR. KIRBY: I haven't seen those comments. As you know we're in
discussions with -- with Turkey about their agreement to take the lead
for security at Hamid Karzai International Airport. We're grateful for
their willingness to do that and we are continuing to work out with them
what the modalities and the details would be going forward.
We obviously anticipate that the United States would be a part of
that security posture at the airport. I can't speak to those comments in
particular.
Dan Lamothe, Washington Post.
Q: Yes, thank you, John. In the last few days President Biden, you,
and some of the other Administration officials have stressed the
capability of the Afghan forces and said there are about 300,000 of
them. Given ghost soldiers, desertions, defections and some of what
we've seen on the battlefield that certainly isn't the case now and
hasn't been for some time.
In addition, the ones who are left, there are many reports of food,
water, ammunition shortages, that sort of thing. Not to put a too fine
of point on it but how do you explain that contradiction and how did the
Pentagon fall so short in training forces that are not only capable on a
given day but sustainable for a long term? Thanks.
MR. KIRBY: I would challenge -- I'd challenge the assumption, Dan,
that we fell short over the course of 20 years. I mean we and
international partner help fund Afghan national defense and security
forces if you include police that numbered as much 352,000.
And now can I give you what the role call and the muster is on any
given day, no, I can't. But I can tell you that we're confident that
over the course of the 20 years we helped raise any army and police
force that numbered over 300,000. Now again, what they're doing on any
given day and who's on the field, that's really a question for our
colleagues in Kabul.
But I take exception to the notion that somehow over the course of 20
years we simply failed in trying to improve the competency and the
capability of Afghan forces when we look at what they're doing today.
It -- it comes down to leadership on the battlefield and leadership
in Kabul and we are not on the battlefield with them. Yes, we're over
the battlefield. I understand we are supporting with limited air strikes
but we aren't in the field with them now. And so these issues of
leadership are issues that Afghan leaders both military and political
have to be able to address.
Q: Doesn't the Pentagon have some culpability in this though? It sounds like you're just passing the buck when you say that.
MR. KIRBY: I'm sorry, Dan. I lost you. Go ahead.
Q: Doesn't the Pentagon have some culpability in this though given
the amount of billions of dollars, the American lives lost, it sounds
like you're passing the buck when you say that.
MR. KIRBY: No, nobody's passing any bucks, Dan. Not at all. I mean
we're all watching this with great concern clearly and the whole
international community. Certainly our NATO Allies. We're also dutifully
involved in combat, lost many lives, lots of sacrifices over the course
of 20 years that we can't forget. Nobody's passing any bucks here.
We -- we have worked hard to improve Afghan competency and capability
in the field. But at some point, and the President has said this very
clearly, at some point that competency and that capability has to be
owned by the Afghans themselves and we are at that point.
Paul Handley.
Q: Hi, John. Can you -- can you hear me, John?
MR. KIRBY: Yes, sir.
Q: OK. Yes, a couple things. One, is when you're talking about
decisions that need to be made by the Afghan leadership, today President
Ashraf Ghani went to the north where he met with Atta Mohammad Noor and
the famous warlord Dostam at Mazar-i-Sharif.
I'm wondering is that the kind of thing that you want to see the --
the Afghan government doing to unite with the old warlords and militia
leaders to fight back the Taliban? And I have a follow-up.
MR. KIRBY: We've seen reports of President Ghani's trip. I certainly
would let him speak to the conversations he had and -- and what the --
what discussions he's having with leaders up in the north. Certainly as
the president of his country and the commander-in-chief of his forces,
he should -- he should make those decisions and have those discussions
that he believes are in the best interest of defending his people and
his territory.
Q: But is that the kind of think you'd like them to see -- do you
think I would be effective for their fight against the Taliban?
MR. KIRBY: Paul, we're not prescribing specific methods of defense
for him. It's his country. He's the commander-in-chief and we're not
going to pass a certain judgment about what discussions he's having or
what other leaders he's meeting with and what they're saying. I mean I
would defer to President Ghani to speak to his discussions and what --
what the goals were, what the objectives were of his visit.
This is, again, he's the commander-in-chief and -- and it's his
political leadership, his political will that can make a big difference
here.
Pierre.
(CROSSTALK)
Q: Does it surprise you that topic of Afghanistan did not come up in
the telephone call between the Secretary and his Russian counterpart.
MR. KIRBY: We provided a readout and I'm going to leave it at that, Pierre. I'm not going to go beyond the readout.
OK, Jared.
Q: Hi, John. Thanks for doing this. Just wondering if you could tell
us the latest -- what is the latest conversation between DOD officials
and their Turkish counterparts on the Kabul Airport mission? And I have a
follow up to that?
MR. KIRBY: I don't have any specific update for you. We continue to
have discussions with the Turks about security at the airport.
Obviously, we're mindful that security at the airport is critical for
our ability to have a diplomatic presence in Afghanistan as well as our
Allies and partners. And so, those discussions are ongoing. I don't have
any updates for you.
Q: OK, and I if might we've seen that the Taliban has alleged that
the U.S. has gone back on its agreements with these airstrikes. Has
there been any consideration that these airstrikes could be potentially
putting the agreed Turkish mission in jeopardy or making it more
challenging or complicated to fulfill?
MR. KIRBY: The airstrikes putting the Turkish mission at more jeopardy?
Q: Because the Taliban has accused the United States of reneging on its agreement.
MR. KIRBY: Well look, it's not the United States that continues to
exert violence on the Afghan people and attempt to try to find a
military solution to what should be a political settlement. It's not the
United States that is now using oppression and brutality and fear to
try to gain some level of governance over parts of Afghanistan. It's not
the United States that is trying to undo what the Taliban have previous
said they were committed to, which was, again, a negotiated political
solution.
We are, as we've said and we've been fairly honest about it, to the
degree we can, continuing to support Afghan forces in the field with the
capabilities that we have available to us.
Last question. Ryo. OK, go ahead.
Q: Thank you. Please let me change the subject a little bit. Today
the Secretary spoke by phone with his Russian counterpart, but the
Secretary has also been waiting to engage with his Chinese counterpart.
Could you give us an update on the Secretary's efforts or progress to
engage with his Chinese counterpart?
MR. KIRBY: I would not say that the Secretary's waiting to engage his
Chinese counterpart. There has been no discussion at his level with a
counterpart in China, and when that makes the most sense, you know,
we'll pursue that, but I have no discussion to announce or to anticipate
or to readout today.
Q: A quick follow up. The -- I'm wondering who is the most
appropriate Chinese counterpart to the U.S. Secretary of Defense for the
DOD perspective? Is that the China's Minister of Defense or Vice
Chairman of the China's Central...
MR. KIRBY: I think we've -- I think we've said clearly that for the
purposes of the kinds of discussions that we think are important with
China it's at the Vice Chairman level.
Q: John, vaccine question?
MR. KIRBY: Yes.
Q: Are you throwing service members in the brig if they refuse to get the jab?
MR. KIRBY: Lucas we talked about this as well yesterday. I'm happy to
go back over it again. We believe that our commanders, should an
individual not want to take the vaccine for other than religious or
medical purposes, then our commanders will have a range of tools
available to them to help these individuals to make the best decision
for them and for their families, for their teammates, that are short of
using the Uniform Code of Military Justice, in other words disciplinary
measures.
Yes. Once a vaccine has been mandated, it becomes a lawful order to
compel an individual to take that vaccine. We do this across the force.
17 some odd vaccines, 8 of which are required just to get into boot
camp. I've been stuck myself all throughout the course of 29 years. It's
not -- we have a process in place and it's just generally not a big
problem. And I -- and as you saw in the Secretary's memo once we get to a
point where we're now executing a new vaccination program, in other
words, mandatory, that he expects commanders will execute that program
with skill and professionalism, and he also used the word compassion.
Understanding that there are trepidations out there. And so, our
expectation is if an individual doesn't want to take the vaccine that
we're going to provide them some counseling both from a medical
perspective, access to docs, and access to leaders in their chain of
command, so that they fully understand the implication and repercussions
to them if they don't take the vaccine, but I don't want to speculate
-- I mean, it'll be a case-by-case basis, Lucas.
It's not -- it's not like the Department's going to have some sort of
blanket disciplinary policy. We expect commanders to use the tools that
they will have available to them to get soldiers and sailors and airmen
and guardians and Marines to do the right thing.
Q: This building has a lot of blanket policies. Can't you just say if
you don't get the vaccine you're going to lose liberty, lose vacation
time, maybe get docked in pay and lose rank?
MR. KIRBY: But, Lucas, we don't do that now for mandatory vaccines.
We don't have a blanket Departmental policy for the polio vaccine or
smallpox or even the flu. I mean, we -- you know, we leave that up to
commanders and their discretion, and like I said, they've got plenty of
tools available to them short of disciplinary action to try to get their
troops to do the right thing.
Q: When you mentioned religious expectations. Which religions are you talking about here?
MR. KIRBY: It doesn't -- there's no -- it's not -- Lucas, there's not
a list of, you know, religions. It's about -- it's about -- it's about
the religious beliefs that an individual might have that they believe
should expect them from the vaccine. And, as I said yesterday, there's a
whole process written down in instruction that governs that process to
include, again, counseling by doctors, counseling by commanders.
And there's -- each Service does this differently. I won't speak for
them to handle these applications for religious exemptions, but it's not
-- you know, it's not like it's written -- there's not a list of
acceptable religions here. It's about taking these concerns by
individuals very seriously, and we take freedom of religion very
seriously in the military.
Q: Yes. John, a lot of what we heard today is frustration, concerns.
Some of the questions seem to focus on inevitability of a negative
outcome, but what are some of the positives that you are seeing from the
Afghan forces right now, and what are some of the positives that you're
seeing from the current U.S. support being provided to the Afghans?
MR. KIRBY: Luis, we have seen -- we have seen Afghan forces fight
back in certain places. In fact, there's fighting going on as we speak.
We have seen the Afghan Air Force be very aggressive. As I've said, they
conducted many more strikes in just the last 24 hours than we have.
They're professional. They're well trained. And they are in the air.
And I would also say, you know, for our perspective, though we are
conducting fewer airstrikes, we're very confident that the strikes we're
conducting are hitting the targets they're meant to hit, that they --
that we are being precise, and that we are having an impact at the
tactical level.
Now clearly from a strategic perspective the Taliban keep advancing.
There is no question about that. But the narrative that in every place
in every way the Afghan forces are simply folding up and walking away is
not accurate. I am not at all and don't -- nobody should take away from
this that I'm discounting what we're seeing, a deteriorating security
situation. We've been nothing but candid about that.
But to your exact question, there are places and there are times,
including today, where Afghan forces in the field are putting up a
fight.
Q: And does that mean that at some point it's possible that the
Afghan forces will be strong enough to reconstitute themselves so that
they could potentially take back...?
(CROSSTALK)
MR. KIRBY: Well, we certainly would like to see that eventuality. As
I've said many times before, no outcome is inevitable here. And the
Afghan forces, they do have -- they do have the capacity to do exactly
that. It's really about the will and the leadership on the field to make
that happen. That's where -- and that's not uncommon in any military.
Equipment, training, all of that is important, but it is often for
naught if you don't have the leadership and the will to use those
advantages to your benefit.
Mike.
Q: But at this point now, has the -- have the Afghan forces recaptured any terrain that was taken by the Taliban?
(CROSSTALK)
MR. KIRBY: I will tell you that, again, without getting into a
battlefield assessment, Mike, because I don't want to do that. There are
-- as we speak, there are places in Afghanistan which are actively
being contested right now.
OK? Thanks, everybody.